Teddy Graham Beach Party Cake
Published on April 28, 2026
If you’re looking for a dessert that will wow everyone at your next summer party, try this Teddy Graham Beach Party Cake. Made with pantry staples and boxed cake mix, you can have your beach ready in less than one hour! Also, great for kid’s birthday parties and summer pool parties.
There are affiliate links in this post – please read my full disclosure policy. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
This beach cake is perfect for parties because you don’t need any special decorating skills or tools. Just use a basic sheet cake, spread on some store-bought frosting for the ocean, and have fun adding candy decorations. Kids love spotting all the details, like the crushed Teddy Graham sand and rainbow candy towels. It always gets people talking and makes your dessert table stand out.
One of the best things about this cake is how easy it is to adapt for your party and the number of guests. Use a 9×13 pan for a big group, or make a smaller round cake for a more intimate celebration. You can switch up the candy decorations depending on what you find at the store or what your birthday child likes best. If you’re throwing a full beach-themed party, this cake goes great with our favorite pool party food, and be sure to check out 25+ *Stunning* Pool Party Birthday Ideas (Perfect for Summer Parties).
Teddy Graham Beach Party Cake Ingredients
Cake Mix: Any flavor works, but vanilla or yellow cake creates the best neutral base for your beach scene.
Blue Frosting: Store-bought makes this cake super easy, or tint white frosting with gel food coloring for a custom ocean shade.
Teddy Graham Cookies: These become both your beachgoers and your edible sand, so grab at least two boxes.
Rainbow Candy Strips: Airheads Xtremes or sour belts work perfectly and cut easily into beach towel shapes.
Peach Ring Candies: These become the cutest little pool floaties for your teddy bear swimmers.
Gummy Sharks: Pick the smaller ones so they’re proportional to your Teddy Graham beach scene.
Paper Drink Umbrellas: Find these in the party supply aisle or order them online for that essential beach vibe.
Step-by-Step Instructions for Your Beach Cake
Bake your cake according to the package directions in a 9×13 inch pan or round cake pan, then let it cool completely before decorating.
Spread blue frosting generously over the entire top of the cooled cake to create your ocean base.
Place about one cup of Teddy Graham cookies in a zip-top bag and crush them into fine crumbs using a rolling pin or your hands.
Sprinkle the Teddy Graham crumbs over half of the frosted cake to create the sandy beach area, leaving the other half as blue ocean.
Cut rainbow candy strips into small rectangles to look like beach towels and arrange them on the sand section of the cake.
Place whole Teddy Graham cookies on the candy towels so they look like they’re sunbathing.
Gently press whole Teddy Grahams into the center of peach ring candies to create bears floating on inner tubes.
Position the peach ring floaties in the blue frosting ocean area.
Stick paper umbrellas into the cake near the teddy bears on the beach for shade.
Add gummy sharks swimming around in the ocean section for a playful finishing touch.
Helpful Tips for Making This Beach Party Cake
Make Ahead:
- Bake and frost the cake up to one day ahead, then cover and refrigerate until you’re ready to add the candy decorations.
- Add the Teddy Graham sand and all decorations within a few hours of serving so the cookies don’t get too soft from the frosting moisture.
Storage:
- Keep the decorated cake covered loosely at room temperature if serving within 4 hours, or refrigerate for up to 2 days.
- The candy decorations hold up surprisingly well, but the Teddy Grahams will soften slightly over time.
Fun Variations and Swaps for Your Teddy Graham Cake
Frosting Options: Whipped cream cheese frosting or buttercream both work beautifully if you want to make frosting from scratch.
- Add a few drops of blue gel food coloring to white frosting for the perfect ocean color.
- Layer two shades of blue frosting for a more realistic water effect with deeper and lighter areas.
Cookie Alternatives: Animal crackers or mini graham crackers work if you can’t find Teddy Grahams, though the teddy bear shape is definitely the cutest option.
- Vanilla wafer crumbs also make convincing sand and taste delicious.
Candy Swaps: Use fruit leather strips instead of rainbow candy for beach towels, or Swedish Fish swimming in the ocean instead of sharks.
- Lifesaver gummies make great floaties too.
- Add rock candy or light brown sugar around the edges for a sparkly sand effect.
Cake Size Options: Make this in a round 9-inch cake pan for a smaller party, or go bigger with a full sheet cake for large gatherings.
- Cupcakes work too if you want individual beach scenes, just use one half blue frosting and one half crushed Teddy Grahams per cupcake.
Theme Variations: Turn this into a pool party cake by using only blue frosting and adding Teddy Grahams on floaties throughout.
- Make it tropical by adding paper palm tree decorations and coconut flakes mixed with the graham cracker sand.
- Create a mermaid version with mermaid birthday party ideas by adding seashell candies and pearl sprinkles.
This Teddy Graham Beach Party Cake is going to be the hit of your summer celebration, guaranteed. It’s one of those desserts where the joy is in both the making and the eating, and watching kids discover all the adorable details never gets old. However you customize it to fit your party theme, it’s going to create those picture-perfect moments that make hosting so rewarding.
Common FAQs
You can bake and frost the cake a day ahead, but wait to add the Teddy Graham crumbs and candy decorations until the morning of your party. The cookies will stay crunchier and look fresher if they haven’t been sitting in contact with the frosting overnight.
Any ring-shaped gummy candy works great as floaties. Try gummy Lifesavers, ring pops without the stick, or even make your own rings by cutting centers out of fruit leather circles. The key is finding something with a hole in the middle that can hold a Teddy Graham.
The trick is not adding them too far in advance. Decorate within 2-3 hours of serving for the best texture. You can also press them gently into the frosting rather than submerging them completely so less of the cookie surface touches the moisture.
Absolutely! Any sturdy cake recipe works beautifully here. Just make sure it’s completely cooled before frosting, and choose a flavor that pairs well with all the candy toppings. Yellow cake, white cake, or even funfetti are all fantastic choices.
Not at all. Keep it in the pan you baked it in, cover it loosely with plastic wrap or a cake dome, and transport it flat in your car. The decorations are surprisingly sturdy once the frosting sets a bit, but drive carefully around turns just to be safe.
Teddy Graham Beach Party Cake
Ingredients
- 1 box Cake Mix (& ingredients listed on box)
- 1 container Blue Frosting
- 1 cup Teddy Grahams crushed, plus more for decorations
- Rainbow Candy Strips
- Peach Rings
- Gummy Sharks
- Paper Umbrellas
Instructions
- Bake the cake mix as instructed on the packaging in a round baking dish and cool completely.
- Frost the cake with blue frosting.
- Crush a cup worth of Teddy Grahams to create sand and sprinkle onto half of the cake.
- Cut the rainbow candy into “towels” and place them on the sand.
- Place candy towels on sand area.
- Add bears to the towels.
- Add teddy bear cookies to the peach rings and place them in the ocean part of the cake.
- Place gummy sharks in ocean section.
